Description:
Submitted to the Members of the
United Nations Committee on the Rights of the Child
by
Ethan Taubes, consultant to
the International League for Human Rights
432 Park Avenue South
New York, New York, 10016, U.S.A
July 1996....Executive Summary:
"Myanmar?s initial report demonstrates a serious lack of understanding for the principles
animating the Convention on the Rights of the Child (CRC). Through its chronic
omission of virtually all relevant information, it describes a country in which children?s
rights are afforded special protection under national law .With its primary emphasis on
reciting enacted legislation, and with little relevant commentary or factual
documentation to fill the gaps, the report avoids any substantive discussion of what
measures Myan.mar is taking to protect children?s rights and enforce existing laws.
SLORC attempts to mask its noncompliance with the Committee?s reporting guidelinesl
by using the subtitle "Implementation" in each section of its report. However, although
the term "implementation" is continually waved like a talismanic wand at the reader, the
sections usually refer to statutory provisions without providing any material on actual
implementation measures the government is taking or, at least, planning to pursue.
Implementation of the Convention does not"end simply with mechanical incorporation
of the CRC provisions into national law .Legislation is meaningless unless it is
accompanied by concrete administrative codes and guidelines for government agencies
to follow and apply .Legislation must be bolstered by specific policy decisions and by
political will to implement the principles of the Convention.2
Article 44(2) of the CRC requires States parties to include in their reports ". ..sufficient
information to provide the Committee with a comprehensive understanding of the
implementation of the Convention in the country concerned," The Myanmar report fails
to satisfy this basic requirement. As a result, it will be all but impossible for the
Committee to conduct discussions "to analyze progress achieved and factors and
difficulties encountered in the implementation of the Convention," as is the
responsibility of the Committee under its guidelines,3
The Committee should require that Myanmar submit another report within six months,
because the current report is not in compliance with the reporting guidelines established
by the Committee and fails to provide the information necessary for the Committee to
conduct its discussions. For this purpose, the Committee should: (1) emphasize, and
elaborate on, the reporting guidelines previously established in the CRC?s Overview on
Reporting Procedures, and (2) require that Myanmar be more forthcoming in its
reporting, especially in its discussion of implementation measures, and demand that the
SLORC not avoid difficult issues about protecting the rights of the Bumiese child."
Source/publisher:
International League for Human Rights
Date of Publication:
1996-07-00
Date of entry:
2012-01-17
Grouping:
- Individual Documents
Category:
Language:
English
Local URL:
Format:
pdf
Size:
893.15 KB